Chuckin’ Stuff

Spring has sprung and the time has come to step out of doors!  Time to shake off the winter doldrums and try out new projects!  Time to BUILD STUFF WITH YOUR KIDS!!!

So, how this came about is that my son, Dylan, wanted to build something — anything.  I am a fair hand at woodworking (I’ve made Adirondack chairs, benches, pergolas, and I did the chair rail and crown moulding in our dining room and built a pretty damn good mantel around our gas fireplace), but I work in fits and starts.  I get excited about a project, then don’t do anything else for months.  If consistency is the hobgoblin of small minds, I must have a HUGE mind.  🙂

So, Dylan wanted to build something, and that got me excited doubly so.  He’s 9 and very much an innocent kid at heart — which I love.  His older sister is 11 going on 21 and I love her, but that can be frustrating (KIDS:  PLS STP GRWNG, THX).  Then I asked what he wanted to build.  So he said a table.  So I said what else.  C’mon, kid, tables we have.  Let’s make this a challenge.  We looked through a bunch of woodworking project sites, proposing then dashing a number of things.  Hockey table?  Too big.  Shelf?  Boring.  Wine rack for Mom?  There’s no way to build one large enough for the expected volume she goes through.  (I kid, I kid, don’t kill me in my sleep!)

Then we saw a cub scout trebuchet.  If you don’t know, a trebuchet is a middle ages siege weapon using counterweights and a long sling to hurl flaming rocks upon and past city walls.  It was the epitome of siege weaponry, but it is kind of esoteric today.  My son asked what it was and told him it was a kind of catapult.

“Hey, Dad, can we build a catapult?”

I love my boy.

Research began.  While a trebuchet is cool, it doesn’t SCREAM “catapult” like the traditional torsion mangonel (what you think of when you picture a catapult).  You know it:  An arm with a spoon or bucket on one end, they crank it down, then release it to slam against a big triangular backstop, unleashing hell downrange.  There’s a whole online community that builds and plays with these things.  After looking at enough pictures, I had a fair idea how one is put together.  Since it was too late to start cutting wood, we hauled out the next best thing:  fishing line and an erector set.

prototype

And it worked pretty damn well too!  It could fling Lego blocks all the way across the room.  If you are not in the know, there are a number of things that go under the name “catapult.”  Many home built ones now use bungees and/or surgical tubing for their action.  This is fine, but not very traditional.  Siege forces simply didn’t have access to elastic materials beyond simple springs and wooden bows.  That would make a “tension” catapult.  What they did have was natural twisted rope and sinew, which is not very stretchy.  Instead of using moments of elasticity, they used “torsion,” energy built up in the twisting of said rope.  The model above is a plastic erector model using twisted fishing line to provide that motive force.

For the larger version, I did more research after Dylan went to bed.  It seems that the spoon or bucket on the throwing arm is — while ubiquitous — not very historically accurate and mostly based upon misinterpretations of old plans.  They were used, but they suffered compared to the Roman onager design.  It’s the same torsion catapult, but it mixes in the sling from the giant trebuchets.  The sling allows for the arm to travel further before it hits the backstop (rather than stopping at a 45 degree angle, it can go all the way to the uprights), and adds extra length for the throw.

I eventually took a bunch of designs, chose the best elements of each, then drew up my own and did the trigonometry myself.  A quick trip to the local hardware store and $56 later, I had all I needed.  My design was for a 3’x2’x18″ model with a 4′ throwing arm and an 18″ sling.  That required about 30′ of 2×6 pine, an 8′ 2×2 pole for the throwing arm, 100′ of twisted nylon rope, three eye bolts, a pin, two 5″ lengths of 3/4″ PVC pipe, and about 45 2.5″ wood screws.  One evening of Daddy-Dylan sawing, drilling, and hammering later:

scorpion

The trickiest part was making the diagonal braces with my atrophied trig.  But, the numbers worked out and they fit in like a glove.  In actuality, the frame is FAR stronger than any conceivable pressure the throwing arm or the torsion bundle could bear upon it, so I anticipate a lot of tinkering before it is optimized.

As it is, the inaugural launch went pretty well.  Our Roman onager, named “Scorpion,” can fling racquetballs about 20 yds, with the potential to go much further.  Our limiting factor right now is the PVC pipes holding the torsion bundle in place.  There was so much pressure on them, they pretty much bent in half, preventing further twisting and giving up a lot of tension.  I’ll be upgrading to steel pipes next.  The guys that do this a lot use curved steel plates, but the old designs used thick arches of wood or metal.  The nylon rope and frame could absolutely stand more pressure.  We also might try a lighter throwing arm and a longer sling.

And, suffice it to say, I get all the “Cool Dad” points for the neighborhood.

Siege On!!!!!

6 thoughts on “Chuckin’ Stuff

  1. next project, try a repeating Chinese crossbow! I never had much luck with tools, a complete klutz. In college, a required class for ALL engineering students was on basic and advanced power tools, routers drills, etc. Term project was to build a 3 inch cube out of half a different thickness sheets of several different metals, using a wide variety of nuts, screws and other fasteners. Supposed to have a mirror finish. The prof looked at my “tinker toy” and cracked up laughing. Rest of the class also, He asked what type of engineering, I said electrical, and he said “Thank God” and gave me a B.

  2. Nice work! Last week my son told me he wants to “build a tornado”. Not too difficult to build the simulator, its basically a box with a fan on top for updraft. What has been challenging, is making a miniature smoke machine so that my seven year old isn’t playing with dry ice…

  3. Interesting. I’ve always thought of trebuchet as an upgrade to catapult. But if you insist catapult screams ‘cool’ louder, I won’t go slinging stones at you.

    • Oh, a trebuchet is definitely a better siege engine, but to a kid, it doesn’t LOOK like a catapult. And once I’ve explained the difference, now he wants a trebuchet. 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s